Every Moment Deserves a Slice of Pie
Thoughtfully crafted Florida Key Lime and Coconut Custard pies for life’s big moments and everyday joy.
Our Sweetest Menu
Thoughtfully crafted in small batches, Sweet Pie Company now specializes exclusively in Florida’s most loved desserts — Key Lime Pie and Coconut Custard Pie.
Made to order with real ingredients and no artificial preservatives, each pie is baked fresh in Gainesville, Florida and designed to bring simple joy to every table.
What Our Pie Lovers Are Saying
-
![]()
Maria Godinez
This pie was scrumptious. From the toasted coconut flakes to the sweet inside it was amazing. I absolutely love this pie.
-
![]()
Alyna Tapia
You can tell this pie was made with love! It was one of the best pies I’ve ever had! Can’t wait until my next order 😀.
-
![]()
Eli Arias
COCONUT PIE? Yes, please! I would never imagine that it would become one of my favorite combinations! The flavor and the crust! Delicious!
-
![]()
Mercedes Herrera
Sweet Pie Company has the best pies. I am not a sweet tooth person but these pies have me coming back again and again. The Key Lime Pie is my personal favorite but all her pies are delicious 😋 the owner goes above & beyond and handles each pie with great care. I will continue to come back to order.
-
![]()
Cathi Bodine
The pies were delivered with so much care, and went above and beyond in so many ways. If I need to send any sweet treats to folks in Gainesville, FL, this will be my go-to place.
-
![]()
Daniela Oquendo
Sweet Pie is such an amazing company, Their Pies are so delicious, My husband and I love all of them and whenever we can you buy more. Best Pie’s ever !!! ❤️
